What is a stock margin analyzer or equity scorecard?
⌄
A stock margin analyzer (also called a multi-factor equity scorecard) scores a company across several financial dimensions — valuation, income, profitability, and solvency — and combines them into a single 0-100 score. This tool applies that approach specifically to Pakistan Stock Exchange (PSX) listed companies using eight weighted financial ratios.
Which financial ratios does this PSX stock analyzer use?
⌄
For standard (non-bank) stocks it uses P/E Ratio, P/BV Ratio, EV/EBITDA, Dividend Yield, Payout Ratio, Return on Equity (ROE), Debt to Equity, and Sales Growth YoY. For banking sector stocks the ratios are swapped for sector-appropriate metrics — see the next question.
How is the total score out of 100 calculated?
⌄
The score is built from four weighted sub-scores — Valuation, Income & Dividends, Profitability (ROE), and Solvency & Growth — each derived from your entered ratios. The sub-scores are then combined using fixed weightings into a single composite score out of 100, with a star rating and undervalued/fair/overvalued label attached.
Is there a separate scoring model for bank stocks on PSX?
⌄
Yes. Switching the toggle to "Banks" replaces general metrics like EV/EBITDA and Debt to Equity with banking-specific ones — Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR) and Net Interest Income Growth — since standard corporate ratios don't apply well to financial institutions.
What is considered a good P/E or P/BV ratio for PSX stocks?
⌄
In this tool's scoring model, a P/E Ratio under 10 and a P/BV Ratio under 1.0 score the highest (5/5), reflecting cheaper relative valuation. These thresholds are general starting points — always compare a stock's ratios against its own sector peers on the PSX rather than a single fixed number.
Can this tool be used to compare two PSX stocks side by side?
⌄
Yes — run the calculator once per stock using its own ratios (available via the Quick Lookup search), note each total score and category breakdown, then compare the results manually. The scorecard format makes it easy to see exactly where one company outperforms another, such as profitability versus solvency.
Can you walk through an example of using this scorecard?
⌄
Say a PSX company shows a P/E of 8, P/BV of 0.9, dividend yield of 6%, payout ratio of 45%, ROE of 18%, and debt-to-equity of 40%. Valuation and Income & Dividends both score highly on figures like these, Profitability lands solid given the healthy ROE, and Solvency & Growth comes in moderate depending on the sales growth entered. The composite typically lands in the 70s — a stock that looks attractively priced with decent income and profitability, but worth a closer solvency check before finalizing a decision.
What common mistakes should I avoid when using this scorecard?
⌄
The most common mistake is comparing a bank's score directly against a standard company's score — they use different metrics entirely (CAR and NII growth versus EV/EBITDA and debt-to-equity), so the numbers aren't on the same scale. Another is treating this composite score as a full replacement for the Stock Health Analyzer or Fair Value Calculator — it's a broad screening tool, and a weak Solvency & Growth sub-score specifically warrants a deeper look with the Health Analyzer before you act on it. And always check the reporting period on your input data; ratios from a stale filing can skew the whole score.